Our PTSD nation - My Web Times

Our PTSD nation

01/30/2009, 10:47 pm  
Comment on this story | Print this story | Email this story
Bill Scheurer, Guest Columnist
My father fought in World War II. My son fought in Iraq. My son has PTSD.

It turns out that my father probably had it too. Only, I never knew it until a friend whose father died years after mine told me about her father.

She told me how this calm intellectual man — who was part of the team of Harvard Law School students that helped draft the U.N. Declaration of Human Rights — would stare off absently in detached moodiness and was given to sporadic fits of violent rage. My own father, also a quiet and gentle man most of the time, showed this same pattern.

She told me that her father, who fought in Europe, never talked about the war. Everything she learned about it, she learned from her mother. My father, who fought in the Pacific, was the same way.

"You know, I'm convinced he had PTSD," she told me. "We didn't have a word for it then, except the 'battle fatigue' or 'shell shock' labels for the most extreme cases, but it's the same thing."

That is when it hit me. We were raised by a generation with PTSD. Nearly 16 million men came home from that war. Came home to families, neighborhoods, schools and jobs — to raise the next generation, the "baby boom" generation — after living the unspeakable horrors of war.

Even the training itself was traumatic. We took young men, still practically children, who our society tried to teach to be kind and loving people, and turned them into young men whose job was to kill and destroy. How can anyone make this leap from teenager to soldier without severe trauma and stress?

Pearl Harbor was the traumatic shock of my parents' generation. It was their Sept. 11. Ever since, our nation has remained on a permanent war footing, from the Cold War to the War on Terror without pause.

Since then, violence and war have flooded our culture in movies, TV shows and now videogames. The leap from teenager to soldier comes more easily these days.

According to "On Killing" by Dave Grossman, only 15 to 25 percent of combat infantry in World War II were willing to shoot at the enemy. They did not run away. They simply would not fire their weapons.

So the military improved its conditioning. The willingness-to-fire figure rose to 50 percent in Korea, more than 90 percent in Vietnam, and approaches nearly 100 percent in Iraq. This may be progress of sorts, if our focus is on producing more soldiers with "zero defect" in their willingness to kill. If our focus is on building healthy citizens and parents in a peaceful society, it may not be so good.

Let me be clear. I am not criticizing our soldiers. I loved my father. I love my son. I am merely noting the costs — to them, to us, and to future generations — of keeping our nation in a permanent state of war: 6 million vets from Korea; 9 million from Vietnam; 2 million from the Gulf War; 2 million more from Iraq.

After so many decades of living with the hidden killer of PTSD, maybe it's time we started looking for other healthier ways to secure the peace for ourselves, our neighbors, and our posterity. With all the emotional and financial investments we keep making in war, maybe it's time to invest a little more in "R&D" on alternatives that do not impose such high costs of trauma and stress?

  • BILL SCHEURER is executive director of Beyond War (www.BeyondWar.org), Editor of PeaceMajority Report (www.PeaceMajority.org), and the author of "us & them: bridging the chasm of faith," a book of interfaith inquiry.


--

Yours for a nonviolent future,

Tom H. Hastings

Director, PeaceVoice Program,

Oregon Peace Institute

2009 PeaceVoice Conference Call for Papers:

http://www.peacevoice.info/?page_id=50

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

http://www.peacevoice.info/

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

member,

Whitefeather Peace Community

3315 N Russet Portland OR 97217

503 327 8250

http://www.whitefeatherpeace.org/

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

faculty

PSU Conflict Resolution MA/MS Program

724 SW Harrison Neuberger 221

Portland OR 97201

503 725 9173

fax 503 725 9174

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

NOTICE: Due to Presidential Executive Orders, the National Security Agency may have read this email without warning, warrant, or notice. They may do this without any judicial or legislative oversight. You have no recourse nor protection save to call for the impeachment of the current President.

Print this story